Discrimination Based on Perception: The Case of Naida Hosan

(image from yahoo.com)

Naida Hosan changed her name to Naida Christian Nova because of the harassment that she received from fellow Army personnel, all because her last name sounded too Islamic. Even though Naida is Catholic, she claims to have been the victim of harassment based on the perception that others had of her religion.

As initially reported by the AP and made front page news on Yahoo!, Naida claims that even her name change and reassignment did not stop the harassment. It eventually led her to check herself into a military hospital because of depression and thoughts of suicide. After formally filing a complaint and request for voluntary discharge, she was instead involuntarily discharged for "ineffective leadership." Citing recent performance appraisals to the contray, Naida filed suit against the Army, who subsequently made an about face and dropped the involuntary discharge. Naida, in turn, dropped the lawsuit and continues to be enlisted in the Army.

This case highlights the fact that discrimination and harassment do not have to be based in the victim being an actual member of a protested class (religion and national origin, in this case), but can characterized by others' perceptions and subsequent treatment of the individual.